Okay, let’s be 16 again. Ready?
We’re going to make a mix-tape.
THE mix-tape.
Because tomorrow is Valentine’s Day.
When I’m bored in class, I make mix-tape lists: The Ultimate Break-Up Mix Tape. Guilty Pleasures. Jenn’s Guide to the Entire History of Women Making Punk Rock (this one is still very much a work-in-progress).
My sister and I used to classify certain songs as “the perfect mix tape song.” There was something undefinable about these ones- a certain je ne sais quoi (god, how long I have been waiting to use that phrase!) that would impart the perfect tone to a mix-tape. Usually it was something exquisitely obscure- a b-side, a rarity, a hidden live track. Off the top of my head, I can remember only two of the songs that were on our list, although we once planned to make an entire mix tape of these ones. “Princess and the Pony,” by Sean Na Na; and “Modern Romance,” by the Yeah Yeah Yeahs. (I would also now add “Music for Evenings,” by the Young Marble Giants, to that list, and “Ex-Boyfriend Beat,” from Skinned Teen.) Of course, a whole tape of these songs would spoil their individual perfection, I realize now; it’s best to sprinkle them, sparkling and sparingly, throughout a mix.
But I digress. I have made many mix-tapes since age fourteen; I have even made my share of crush tapes, although it’s been a long time since I felt any compulsion to compose one of those. The crush tape is a delicate, fragile creation- ideally, it will be pored over by your sweetheart, as they attempt to understand the contents of your heart refracted through the words of others.
Pop songs are so inclined toward hyperbole when it comes to relationships, and thus, it’s very difficult to assemble a crush tape that is both charming and truthful. When you are still in the first blush of a budding romance, you do not want to pull out all the stops and record something like Dolly Parton’s “I Will Always Love You” onto your cassette. Conversely, you do not want to be so informal about your song selection that you make the mistake of picking a tune that you like quite well, but have never listened closely to the lyrics … and when you finally do, a few weeks after handing over the tape, you realize that you have given them “Long Black Veil” or some similarly baffling choice.
Some of the sweetest tunes I can think of for a crush tape: “Sweet Heart Fever,” by Scout Niblett (which I actually received on a crush tape, once; at least, I think it was a crush tape. See above reference to “poring over tape & extracting meaning”).
Nearly anything from 69 Love Songs, by the Magnetic Fields; I especially prefer “Acoustic Guitar” these days (“The Book of Love” falls into the Dolly Parton category, unless you have already professed; in which case, crush mix-tapes are kind of beside the point).
I know I wrote down some other ones; probably Mirah or the Blow or something. The greatest problem with these kinds of tapes, though, is this: the best songs are never happy songs. The best songs are the ones written on the edge of hysteria (often inspired by heartbreak). The songs that you save for the day after Valentine’s Day, when you wake up and it’s still winter and your only company is unrequited love. The sad bastard music: Carissa’s Wierd, or some particularly heartbreaking Ryan Adams; maybe, when you get over the sadness and move onto subverted sexual frustration, you could put on the Violent Femmes or Kevin Blechdom. Or, the ultimate don’t-need-you song collection: Fleetwood Mac’s Rumours.
But today, it’s still the 13th; if you run to the store, you still have time to grab that 60-minute cassette, and spend your evening with some Jonathan Richman records, trying to decide which song you will commit to tape to make that perfect crush statement: the one that expresses your admiration while still remaining a little mysterious about the depth of your feelings.
Godspeed.