You know when you’ve just finished a very good book? One you’ve been working on for a while- and then, abruptly, it’s over, and you’re thrust out of that world and back into your living room/bedroom/seat on the bus? But you’ve been so wrapped up in this other place that you aren’t yet ready to return to your life, and you just sit there, holding the book, and dwelling on what you’ve read, and wishing that you could find a way to get back there?
I saw the Bob Dylan movie yesterday- you know, that one where, like, six different actors play versions of him? It got under my skin, they way films never do. I’m not much of a movie person- for whatever reason, they just don’t resonate with me the way that books or music do. It is much easier for me to inhabit a story or a song. Actually, that kind of holds true for my relationship with Bob Dylan’s music, too- it doesn’t let me in. I appreciate it, I listen to it, but I never take it fully under my skin.
But I walked out of the Pickford last night, and didn’t have words. The film hit me where books hit me: when they’re over, I’m still too immersed in my interior world to be able to translate the experience to the external world. It was not good, or bad, or any one thing. I would use words like, “phenomenal,” or “brilliant,” but they don’t have any meaning in this context. How do you summarize ten completely different films in a sentence or two?
Most of it was just giant inside jokes- in one of the many parts that put me in mind of A Mighty Wind, Julianne Moore talks to her cats and plays the role of a Joan Baez character. And there’s that one scene that’s totally a reference to the cover of “The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan”! But there is substance, also. Todd Haynes has done that unique thing- he has striking imagery, and obscure references, and intriguing story-telling- he has married both style & content, in a film that contains both Richard Gere’s circus-village-at-the-apocalypse and Cate Blanchett’s reflections on the inadequacies of pop music.
I don’t intend a film review. There are already plenty of people who regurgitate films on the internet. But Cate Blanchett’s Jude Quinn is fantastic, revelatory, a female understanding of masculinity that confounds and reminds one of how rarely this gender presentation appears in mainstream film.
And there was a part in the middle, where one of the Dylan characters defends himself against charges of chauvinism, saying something along the lines of this: “I adore women! Everyone should have one!” His wife goes all Cixous on him. And I felt that the ghost of Ellen Willis was vindicated.


