Who were your starter bands? For me: the Clash, for sure; Sleater-Kinney; maybe even Mirah; and, you know- the major indie rock bands. Death Cab for Cutie; Modest Mouse; even … dare I say it?
Uh, Bright Eyes.
I thought I was pretty rock ‘n roll, wearing around my Bright Eyes shirt that I bought on the Lifted tour- you might have seen it. Navy blue and brown, the one with bats flying around the kids and the record player. Oh, so emo, at a time when being emo filled my heart with pride!
Yet while Sleater-Kinney and Mirah continue to give me great joy & inspiration, and I really enjoy a London Calling listen from time to time, Bright Eyes and most of my other starter bands are relegated to the “guilty-pleasure” corner of my music collection. (Alongside the Aquabats, and- well, nevermind.) Although “guilty pleasure” may be a bit of a misnomer- really, these are the artists I have completely lost interest in, except for the occasional nostalgic replay.
Which is kind of weird, when I reflect upon it. Because Death Cab & I? We were together for a LONG time. And same with Modest Mouse. And my fling with Bright Eyes, while more brief than the others, was torrid and all-consuming.
Abruptly, however, I lost interest in these bands, and did not realize until months later that my attention had shifted. My critics will point out that this loss-of-interest occurred, coincidentally, at the same time that these bands started to get a lot of attention (aka: when emo kids replaced goths in high schools across the country, and Garden State introduced the world to “New Slang”).
I am a music snob sometimes- this is true and inarguable. But I am not satisfied with the explanation that I stopped liking Death Cab just because everyone else caught on to them. Falling out of love with someone is usually due to a whole range of reasons- likewise, there is something else going on when I stop listening to one of my Top-Fiver’s. It’s not like I just I woke up one morning and was no longer attracted to them.
Thus, I would like to propose a justification for my seemingly-asshole tendencies. And, perhaps, for the actions of my fellow music snobs. Extending my cheesy metaphor, I offer the following narrative.
I discover a band. I begin to listen obsessively- the best ones often take weeks or months for me to fully warm up to. I wake up in the middle of the night with their lyrics stuck in my head. Once in a while, my own inability to verbally express what they mean to me might make my heart ache. They (currently: Electrelane) become one of the musical touchstones of my soul.
People catch on! And by “people catching on,” I don’t even mean “they are appearing on MTV at all hours of the day and night!” First of all, I’m pretty sure that MTV doesn’t air music videos anymore. What I really mean is: my secret is out! And other people also like ‘em! Which should be good- I should be excited to share something good & spread the gospel of my favorite band, right? NO. Because:
This makes me realize that my relationship with chosen band is not a unique soulmate monogamous relationship.
3.5. It is not just other people liking the band. If the other people appreciated them with the full depth of emotion that I bestow upon them, it would be fine. But these people are CASUAL LISTENERS. Some of whom have bad tastes.
- I want to have a respectful, loving, and monogamous relationship with you, _ (name a band that has fallen from my favor)! But you keep sleeping with all those people who listen to Dave Matthews, and giving other signs that you reciprocate their affections (via signing to major labels, appearing on Letterman, or other signs of “selling out”).
There are few greater turn-offs than realizing that you share the object of your passion with someone you don’t respect.
- In order to salvage my own self-respect, I have to end this relationship, and I will regard you henceforth with the mingled shame & regret I reserve for love I have outgrown.
Dear Ben Gibbard, Rocky Votolato, Isaac Brock, Conor Oberst, and all others who have not lived up to my exacting standards of love: sorry if this is not fair. I mean, it isn’t fair. But we have gone our separate ways, and are now the stronger & better for it. And through we were not meant to be together forever, you introduced me to the folks who currently float my boat. So, thanks for guiding me to my future happinesses.